Disgusting-tasting moths don't bother trying to escape predators
A study has found that tasty moths work harder to avoid being eaten by bats.
It might seem like they are being lazy, but actually some moths do not bother to flee from predators because they taste disgusting.
Some of the less appetising winged insects are more nonchalant when attacked by bats while their tastier friends tend to employ evasive manoeuvres, a new study suggests.
Moths were observed to see if they used these ducking and diving tactics while the bats were watched to see if they consumed the bugs or spat them out. Researchers say their findings show the risks and rewards of anti-predator strategies where mistakes can inevitably mean death.
Many creatures in the animal kingdom have evolved defence tactics to evade and deter potential predators. In moths, this includes chemical defences that make them less appetising, ultrasonic hearing to hear bats approaching and mid-flight swoops and dives to avoid being eaten.
Read more about insects:
- How an extraordinary letter to Darwin spotted industrial melanism in moths
- Five ways deadly diseases carried by mosquitoes have steered the course of human history
Dr Nicolas Dowdy, of the Milwaukee Public Museum and Wake Forest University in the US, noticed unusual behaviour in certain species of tiger moths. They seemed to be relatively relaxed when attacked by predatory bats, prompting scientists to investigate the reasons behind this casual behaviour.
The researchers hypothesised that nonchalant moths have evolved chemical defences that made them unpalatable, meaning they have less motivation to evade bats than their more delicious moth counterparts.
In order to test this theory the researchers collected five different species of tiger moths and then released them in an outdoor “flight arena” at night, where wild bats would frequently swoop in to feed.
More like this
Using infrared cameras they monitored interactions between the bats and moths and recorded how often different species displayed evasive or nonchalant behaviour during a bat attack. They also measured how palatable the moths were to the bats.
Dr Dowdy said: “Strikingly, we observed that moths with weak or no chemical defences often dive away to escape bat attacks. However, moths with more potent chemical defences are more ‘nonchalant’, performing evasive manoeuvres less often.”
According to the study published in the Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution journal, this correlation allowed the researchers to predict the evasive or nonchalant behaviour of the moths based on their palatability.
When considering why the insects did not just try to evade the bats anyway, researchers suggest that the method poses both risks and rewards. As well as being exhausting, performing panicked evasive manoeuvres might help a moth avoid becoming dinner but it might also land it in a spider’s web or away from a food source or mate.
Dr Dowdy speculated that unsavoury moths may often take the lazier and potentially safer option by relying on their chemical defences rather than roll the dice on an emergency flight. It may be possible that this relationship between palatability and nonchalance exists elsewhere in the animal kingdom but future studies are needed, say the scientists.
Reader Q&A: Why don’t moths fly towards the Sun?
Asked by: Matthew Snowdon, Bristol
Most moths are nocturnal, so during the day they keep still to avoid detection from predators. Moths don’t fly towards the Moon, either: the idea that moths are trying to navigate by the Moon has been disproved.
Exactly why moths fly towards artificial lights still isn’t understood – all we know is that artificial lights confuse them in some way.
Subscription offers you will love!
- Spread the cost and pay just £3.50 per issue when you subscribe to BBC Science Focus Magazine.
- Alternatively, lock in for longer and pay just £37.99 per year, saving 51%!
- Risk - free offer! Cancel at any time when you subscribe via Direct Debit.
- FREE UK delivery.