Are you living in a simulation? The strange reason you’ll never have the answer

Elon Musk has speculated that we might be living in a simulation. If we are, then what is real and outside of this simulation?

Try 6 issues for £9.99 when you subscribe to BBC Science Focus Magazine!
Published: February 20, 2023 at 11:00 am

There is no way to know what's outside of the simulation. This isn’t just unknown, in the way that the existence of life after death, or parallel universes, is unknown; it is an unanswerable question. Let’s suppose that we are in a computer simulation, either created by a higher intelligence or humans in the future.

Nowimagine that through some bug left in the code, we are accidentally able to step beyond the constraints of our programming and ‘see’the simulation’sraw scaffolding, like Neo inThe Matrix. How would you be able to decide whether this lay outside the simulation, or was still part of it–as a joke or anEaster egg, put there by programmers?

Could you even definitively say that the columns of ones and zeros scrolling past your eyes proved that reality was a simulation at all? Maybe that’s just what theUniverse is made of, once you zoom all the way in past the atoms and quarks.

And even if you were able to unplug yourself and emerge blinking into the higher reality, how do you knowthis is what it is? Perhaps there is another reality around that, and so on. If none of these realities are reachable except in our imaginations, are they real? Reality comprises the things we can measure; everything else is fantasy or speculation.

Asking what lies beyond this reality is like asking whowewere beforebeingborn. Shakespeare’s Hamlet tells Horatio that there are more things inHeaven andEarth than are dreamt of in his philosophy. But it may be the other way round. Humans are good at dreaming up things that do not exist, so you can’t use your ability to imagine something as evidence for it, one way or another.

Read more:

Asked by: Tony H Worcester,via email

To submit your questions email us at questions@sciencefocus.com (don't forget to include your name and location)