Can Yerba Mate tea actually crush your afternoon fatigue? Here’s what the science says

It's Lionel Messi’s miracle drink.

Try 6 issues for £9.99 when you subscribe to BBC Science Focus Magazine!
Published: July 2, 2023 at 5:00 pm

When Lionel Messi, one of the world’s best football players, posted a picture on Instagram of yerba mate, everyone wanted to know about the green drink and whether we should all be sipping it. Well, it turns out the tea-like beverage does have a number of health benefits.

Yerba mate is the national drink in a number of south American countries, consumed as a morning pick-me-up in the same way Brits might have a cup of coffee or tea. But yerba mate teabags and energy drinks, promising ‘a natural energy boost’ are starting to be sold on UK high streets. So, should you swap your morning cuppa for a gourd of yerba mate?

Also known as chimarrao, yerba mate is a traditional South American infused drink, particularly in Uruguay, Argentina, Paraguay, southern states of Brazil. Image credit: Getty images
Also called chimarrão, yerba mate is a traditional South American infused drink, particularly in Uruguay, Argentina, Paraguay, and the southern states of Brazil. Image credit: Getty images

The energy boost that yerba mate offers is partly down to its caffeine content, which is about 80mg per 150ml. It’s hard to compare this to a ‘regular’ cup of coffee because caffeine is affected by brewing time, bean choice, and other factors. But a study byWhich?found that an average mug of tea contains 75mg, while a mug of instant coffee has around 100mg and a cappuccino from a coffee shop anywhere from 66-325mg.

Unless you have barista-made drinks every day, it’s unlikely that swapping your morning cuppa for yerba mate would make much difference to your caffeine intake. But many people say that yerba mate has the wake-up properties of coffee without its afternoon energy crash.

Exactly why yerba mate drinkers avoid the caffeine crash is unknown, although it could be because the tea contains small amounts of two other stimulants, theobromine and theophylline, that stay in your body longer than caffeine. Theobromine has a longer half-life: 7-12 hours, compared to caffeine’s 2.5-5 hours.

Yerba mate also contains antioxidants in the form of polyphenols, which help protect our cells from damage, while an extract form of yerba mate has been found to be slightly anti-inflammatory.

A study of 102 people who drank yerba mate three times a day saw an 8.7 per cent reduction in their levels of LDL cholesterol (the ‘bad’ cholesterol linked to heart disease and stroke). The extract is of particular interest to weight loss researchers, and small studies have shown that yerba mate supplements can decrease body fat percentages and appetites.

Other studies show that the extract increases fat burning during exercise and is thought to delay the onset of fatigue, which makes it appealing for endurance athletes. But, it’s unclear whether these benefits also apply to the brewed drink.

There are, however, concerns about the hot temperature at which yerba mate is traditionally served, as they could pose an increased risk of cancers of the throat and mouth – though drinking hot coffee can increase risk of some cancers, too.

Read more:

To submit your questions email us at questions@sciencefocus.com (don't forget to include your name and location)