What does the world look like outside of our brains?
Without our brain, can we ever really know how to interpret all the sensory information?
Asked by: Nye Lewis-Davies
Your question has echoes of the American philosopher Thomas Nagel’s classic paper “What is it like to be a bat?” – a creature that is able to navigate using echolocation (by bouncing sounds off the environment). Nagel wrote that we can never step outside of our own brain and take the bat’s perspective on the world because we lack their sensory equipment.
Likewise, one could argue that we can never know what the world ‘looks like’ free from our brains because we can only perceive objective reality through the veil of our senses, such as via wavelengths of light hitting our retina, or odorous molecules stimulating nerve cells in our nose.
We can’t even ever truly know if the world looks the same from the perspective of another human brain. For instance, the colour that I label ‘red’ may subjectively look different to you than it does to me.
We know as a matter of fact that there are aspects of physical reality that we cannot detect ourselves – such as radio waves, ultraviolet light (detectable by birds and bees, among other creatures) and high-pitched ultrasound (used by bats). And of course, there are likely many other aspects of reality not yet detectable by any creature or our most advanced technology – a possibility that fuels the imagination of science fiction writers and mystics alike.
More like this
But while our take on the world is restricted by the limitations of our own neurological systems, it would be a mistake to underplay their potential. For starters, we have way more than five senses (among the other are balance, hunger and proprioception – the sense of where our body is in space).
What’s more, recent research suggests that it may be possible for us to learn a form of echolocation, by making clicks with our mouths. Indeed, some blind people can already do this, using the echoes to piece together their environment as a bat would.
- When we start uploading our brains to computers, will our sense of self be uploaded too?
- How much information can your brain store?
- If the brain has no pain receptors, why do I get headaches?
- What happens in your brain when you make a memory?
Subscribe to BBC Science Focus Magazine for fascinating new Q&As every month and follow @sciencefocusQA on Twitter for your daily dose of fun facts.
Dr Christian Jarrett is a cognitive neuroscientist, science writer and author. He is the Deputy Editor of Psyche, the sister magazine to Aeon that illuminates the human condition through psychology, philosophy and the arts. Jarrett also created the British Psychological Society's Research Digest blog and was the first ever staff journalist on the Society's magazine, The Psychologist. He is author of Great Myths of The Brain and Be Who You Want: Unlocking the Science of Personality Change.
- Try your first 6 issues for just £9.99 when you subscribe to BBC Science Focus Magazine.
- Risk - free offer! Cancel at any time when you subscribe via Direct Debit.
- FREE UK delivery.
- Stay up to date with the latest developments in the worlds of science and technology.